![]() Now I want to restate that I don't simply believe that Ryukishi simply made a mistake. The red truth, the highest authority in this game, testifies against the Shkanon theory. Shannon and Kanon not only aren't the same person, but they can't be the same person. But even if you do that, you still run into fatal problems, since Yasu would have more than two personalities and would still be a person, even if she never made up her Shannon and Kanon personality, so at the very least, she would have three personalities, arguably four. "People" is defined as "living human bodies", not "personalities", so even if you want to claim that it refers to personalities, you are simply making that up without evidence. Would that make any sense at all? It doesn't matter how you take it. Then that means that even though Yasu still exists on the island, it could be stated in red that there are no people on the island. In other words, let's say that everyone, apart from Yasu, dies, and then Yasu then kills her Shannon and Kanon personalities. But if you take that to the logical conclusion, when you assume that "people" can actually refer to personalities, then the following would have to be true, that Yasu herself doesn't fall in the category of "people". So what many believers in the official explanation believe is that Yasu can kill her own personalities, meaning that Shannon and Kanon can die without Yasu dying. And in the third game, Shannon and Kanon are both confirmed dead in the first twilight. For example, in the second game, there is the red statement that Kanon was killed in Jessica's room. If "people" means "personalities", then Shkanon is wrong.Īnd this becomes even more apparent when you consider that most believers in the official explanation believe that Yasu can let her personalities "die" without her body dying. If people means "bodies", then Shkanon is wrong. confirms) or to personalities (as the Shkanon believers simply made up.) In either case, there is a conflicting red statement. So it doesn't matter whether people refers to bodies (as in the red. But even if there would be just 2 personalities to Yasu, then that "17 people" statement actually disproves the Shkanon theory, because it shows that there are 17 personalities on the island, even when Erika is included. Namely, you have Yasu herself, her "Shannon" theory, and her "Kanon" personality, and one could argue that you would even need to include her "Beatrice" personality as well, so that would make 3, if not 4, personalities, rather than 2. After all, if Shannon and Kanon are both personalities of Yasu, then we are not dealing with merely two personalities to begin with, but at least three. There is no evidence for such an interpretation, and there is evidence against it. ![]() In other words, saying the "people" can refer to "personalities" is nothing other than your own, arbitrary opinion. First, it still goes against the definition of "people" given in the 6th novel.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |